
Does your PhD make you feel constrained and limited? Do you sometimes feel as though you’re being funnelled down a narrow tube of super-specialisation?
If your answer is ‘Yes’, you can console yourself with the fact that it’s hardly surprising!
Having reached the pinnacle of the qualification hierarchy (Level 8 in the European Qualifications Framework), you’re now an expert in a very narrow and specific area of knowledge. Indeed, you can barely see the wood for the trees đ
That’s a bit cheeky, I know, but I wanted to highlight how our broad subject interests, which begin in nursery and primary school and become progressively narrower as we move through the education system.
By the time you reach the PhD, your intellectual horizons may have narrowed to an extraordinarily small corner of the knowledge universe. And that’s precisely what makes you experts.
I say this as someone who didn’t go through with a PhD, but who did spend three years as a research assistant investigating a transport mechanism in plants. My original motivation for taking the post was to make a difference in the world by discovering ways to improve plant nutrition in developing countries.
Needless to say, my research was about as far removed from a real-world application as walking slowly â three steps forward, two steps back â from the UK to said developing countries. Slower, in fact!
And that’s fine for those who relish their research and the intense focus that creating new knowledge affords. Many PhD graduates go on to become research group leaders and professors, delving ever more deeply into their chosen research disciplines, becoming recognised experts in their fields and enjoying it along the way.
Of course, academic careers can broaden too, as researchers take on responsibilities for teaching, leadership, management, mentoring and collaboration. So, while their subject expertise may remain relatively specialised, their professional activities and skills can become much more diverse.
However, for the majority of PhD graduates (and postdocs too), whether through choice or necessity, remaining in the academic part of the funnel is not an option.
And this is where the challenges can begin.
Having spent years progressing through an education system that encourages increasing specialisation, researchers may find that their professional identity has become inextricably linked to their research and academia.
So, it’s hardly surprising that moving beyond academia can be difficult. After all, it’s not simply a matter of finding another job. It may also involve reimagining who you are professionally, recognising the broader value of your skills and experiences, and adjusting to a different working environment.
The process varies enormously depending on individual circumstances.
For example, those who are keen to leave academia and have a career strategy may find it a relief to move into roles such as senior scientist, science communicator or consultant, particularly when these are connected to their research expertise.
Others may feel they’re being forced out because of a scarcity of permanent positions, limited funding or intense competition for academic posts. For them, the transition can be more traumatic, involving a sense of loss as well as uncertainty about the future.
And for those considering careers that have little or no connection to their research discipline, the challenge of recognising their transferable skills, making new connections and presenting themselves convincingly to employers can seem particularly daunting.
But here’s the interesting thing about the career funnel.
Although your subject expertise becomes progressively narrower during your education and research career, your potential career opportunities don’t necessarily follow the same trajectory. In fact, they can become much broader.
The further you move away from your specific research discipline, the more varied the possibilities may become. From academic research to industry R&D, science communication, policy, consulting, management, finance and even careers that have no obvious connection to your PhD subject at all.
Your expertise may have narrowed, but your career horizons don’t have to.
And here’s another thought: you don’t have to wait until you finish your PhD or postdoc to start widening them.
I like to call this process ‘de-narrowing’.
Even while you’re immersed in highly specialised research, you can actively broaden your experiences, interests, skills and professional networks.
For example, you might organise a conference, join a committee, volunteer, mentor students, undertake an internship or placement, participate in outreach activities, collaborate with researchers from other disciplines or connect with professionals working outside academia.
These activities don’t just add transferable skills to your CV. They can also introduce you to new people, different working environments and alternative ways of using your expertise.
Importantly, they can help you begin to see yourself as more than a specialist in one particular research topic.
In other words, you can start exploring the wider end of the career funnel while you’re still in its narrowest part!
So, what’s my take-home message?
- Don’t be hard on yourself if you’re finding it difficult to move into the broader part of the career funnel. Changing direction after years of specialisation isn’t necessarily easy, particularly when your professional identity is closely associated with academia.
- Don’t keep quiet. Seek support from peers, alumni, friends, family and, in particular, professional career advisers and coaches who can help you make sense of your options and develop a way forward.
- Start early. If you know your contract is coming to an end, don’t wait until your final week to take action. Reflect on your interests, skills and values, and consider how these might translate into different career opportunities.
- Don’t limit yourself. Your knowledge of the world of work can expand or restrict your career horizons. The more you discover about different roles, sectors and employers, the more possibilities you’re likely to recognise.
- Don’t feel you have to apply for everything. Try to remain positive, even when you’re feeling uncertain, and give yourself time to explore your options, develop a career strategy and connect with professionals who can offer useful insights.
- Take advantage of career development opportunities. Workshops, coaching, placements, networking events and other professional development activities can be invaluable, especially when they’re freely available through your institution.
- And, above all, start de-narrowing! Look for opportunities to broaden your experiences and perspectives, even while you’re concentrating on your research.
Remember, a PhD may make you an expert in a very narrow field, but it doesn’t mean you’re destined to remain there.
The funnel narrows your subject expertise, but it doesn’t have to narrow your future.
Related posts: Career development – it’s personal
10 ways to find your next job
Career Horizons









